The pillars of identity are the embarrassing puzzle for those who have lost them
How do you eliminate the dreams of Lakhdar bin Kulah and everyone who glorifies the Phoenician and Canaanite languages at the expense of the Amazigh language? With conclusive evidence: (from experience)
I know the pillars of identity well:
What are the pillars of identity:
Earth. Language. History.If your opponent is ignorant of it, then familiarize him with it, because the issue of the pillars of identity is necessary before anything else, and because they are fixed points, if one of them is omitted, the argument at hand is invalid.
The beginning of the discussion will begin by explaining to you through history that he proves that the land is Phoenician and that any form of change that occurred in North Africa originally had a role through the Phoenician or the Canaanite, and with this projection he wants to put you in doubt that the Amazighs do not exist, but rather they were Phoenicians or Canaanites or even Yemenites, They even invented the name “Amazigh” themselves, and they later obscured their true identity.
If things go like this, he will also try to present to you traces that prove the existence of the Phoenicians and Canaanites, that their symbols existed, except for you, you amazigh, who lacks a compass and cannot see well.
If that is the case, put in your introduction the two pillars of “Land + History.” It does not matter if they are real or fake, it does not matter to us.
The last pillar remains, which is the language that separates the false claim from the true one, and here he will try to prove to you that “Tifinagh” is nothing but a phrase from the Musnad from Yemen, or it is originally “Tifinagh” a Phoenician script, and that Amazigh is nothing but Phoenician, Punic, Canaanite, and then its word was hybridized. In colloquial dialect or in Arabic, and for this reason you stop at one point, which is the language. Is there anyone who speaks Phoenician? Is there a person who speaks Canaanite? Where is the Phoenician/Canaanite tongue now?
The language must be in the tongue of the individual whose identity proves it. Without it, the human being would not exist at all. Put this challenge to him if it is proven that there is a person who speaks Phoenician, Canaanite, or even Punic in this world, then this proves the integrity of the required identity. As for a challenge that does not exist, they all flee from this. The question in particular is because they do not have complete evidence to prove this because they are languages that are essentially extinct.
Thus, their claim to the Phoenician or Canaanite identity with which they want to erase the Amazigh language is dropped, and from ignorance only their followers, devoid of reason and logic, laugh.
As for you, establish these pillars for him so that you can argue with convincing evidence, and we are not sophists or sellers of illusion. Rather, it is an established truth, and whoever leaves it will be lost in the swamp of ignorance, then he will sell his assets in weakness, and will only see out of hatred and malice:
The Amazigh language bears witness to its language and has not yet become extinct like Phoenician and Canaanite The earth bears witness to its existence before you were on it, and who are you? Amazigh history has enough to prove that it is the most deserving of glorification and then victory on this earth, and we have heroes.All three of these elements achieve what is required and highlight the complete Amazigh identity.
Source: websites